Commonwealth of Massachusetts SUFFOLK SUPERIOR COURT Case Summary Civil Docket Pilotte v Sheen et al -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Details for Docket: SUCV1999-05273 Case Information Docket Number: SUCV1999-05273 Caption: Pilotte v Sheen et al Filing Date: 11/03/1999 Case Status: Disposed: by Settlement Status Date: 03/31/2000 Session: Civil G, 3 Pemberton Square, Boston Lead Case: NA Case Type: Appeal from District Court Tracking Deadlines TRK: X Discovery: Service Date: 02/01/2000 Disposition: 05/31/2000 Rule 15: Rule 12/19/20: Final PTC: 05/01/2000 Rule 56: Answer Date: 04/01/2000 Jury Trial: YES -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Parties Involved -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4 Parties Involved in Docket: SUCV1999-05273 Party Involved: Role: Defendant Last Name: Sheen First Name: Shuh Address: Address: City: State: Zip Code: Zip Ext: Telephone: Party Involved: Role: Defendant Last Name: Sheen First Name: Volney Address: Address: City: State: Zip Code: Zip Ext: Telephone: Party Involved: Role: Defendant Last Name: Silipigno First Name: John Address: Address: City: State: Zip Code: Zip Ext: Telephone: Party Involved: Role: Plaintiff Last Name: Pilotte First Name: Nancy Address: Address: City: State: Zip Code: Zip Ext: Telephone: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Attorneys Involved -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 8 Attorneys Involved for Docket: SUCV1999-05273 Attorney Involved: Firm Name: FULL01 Last Name: Donohue First Name: John P Address: 339 Main Street Address: City: Worcester State: MA Zip Code: 01608 Zip Ext: Telephone: 508-751-5128 Tel Ext: Fascimile: 508-757-1039 Representing: Silipigno, John (Defendant) Attorney Involved: Firm Name: SMIT08 Last Name: Swartz First Name: Jeffrey D Address: Suite 2303 Address: 350 Granite Street City: Braintree State: MA Zip Code: 02184 Zip Ext: Telephone: 617-770-2214 Tel Ext: Fascimile: 617-774-1714 Representing: Sheen, Shuh (Defendant) Attorney Involved: Firm Name: Last Name: Noon First Name: Richard E Address: Charles Gale & Assoc Address: 209 West Central St., Suite 103 City: Natick State: MA Zip Code: 01760 Zip Ext: Telephone: 978-371-0000 Tel Ext: Fascimile: 508-907-7016 Representing: Sheen, Shuh (Defendant) Attorney Involved: Firm Name: Last Name: Noon First Name: Richard E Address: Charles Gale & Assoc Address: 209 West Central St., Suite 103 City: Natick State: MA Zip Code: 01760 Zip Ext: Telephone: 978-371-0000 Tel Ext: Fascimile: 508-907-7016 Representing: Sheen, Volney (Defendant) Attorney Involved: Firm Name: STRO01 Last Name: Browne First Name: E Robert Address: 169 Merrimack Street Address: City: Lowell State: MA Zip Code: 01852 Zip Ext: Telephone: 978-371-0000 Tel Ext: Fascimile: 978-452-5690 Representing: Sheen, Shuh (Defendant) Attorney Involved: Firm Name: SMIT08 Last Name: Swartz First Name: Jeffrey D Address: Suite 2303 Address: 350 Granite Street City: Braintree State: MA Zip Code: 02184 Zip Ext: Telephone: 617-770-2214 Tel Ext: Fascimile: 617-774-1714 Representing: Sheen, Volney (Defendant) Attorney Involved: Firm Name: Last Name: Blair First Name: Gerald F Address: One Fox Hill Drive Address: Suite 110 City: Walpole State: MA Zip Code: 02081 Zip Ext: 4406 Telephone: 508-660-9599 Tel Ext: Fascimile: 508-660-9555 Representing: Pilotte, Nancy (Plaintiff) Attorney Involved: Firm Name: STRO01 Last Name: Browne First Name: E Robert Address: 169 Merrimack Street Address: City: Lowell State: MA Zip Code: 01852 Zip Ext: Telephone: 978-371-0000 Tel Ext: Fascimile: 978-452-5690 Representing: Sheen, Volney (Defendant) -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Calendar Events -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- No Calendar Events found for Docket: SUCV1999-05273. There are currently no calendar events associated with this case. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Full Docket Entries -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 65 Docket Entries for Docket: SUCV1999-05273 Entry Date: Paper No: Docket Entry: 11/03/1999 Appeal from Boston Municipal Dist Crt filed 11/03/1999 Origin 4, Type F04, Track X. 11/03/1999 1 Complaint 11/03/1999 2 ANSWER AND CROSSCLAIM: Defendant Shuh Sheen 11/03/1999 3 Amended ANSWER AND CROSSCLAIM: Defendant Shuh Sheen 11/03/1999 4 ANSWER by John Silipigno to CROSSCLAIM of Shuh Sheen 11/03/1999 5 ANSWER AND CROSSCLAIM: Defendant John Silipigno 11/03/1999 6 SERVC RETRND: Shuh Sheen (Defendant) by leaving at the last and usual 11/03/1999 6 place of abode on 12/20/97 11/03/1999 7 SERVC RETRND: John Silipigno (Defendant) by leaving at the last and 11/03/1999 7 usual place of abode on 12/22/97 11/03/1999 8 Affidavit by Atty Blair for service of complaint re: Shuh Sheen 11/03/1999 8 (return receipt attached) 11/03/1999 9 Motion of Plaintiff to Amend Complaint (to add defendant) 11/03/1999 10 ANSWER by Shuh Sheen to CROSSCLAIM of John Silipigno 11/03/1999 11 ANSWER by John Silipigno to Amended CROSSCLAIM of Shuh Sheen 11/03/1999 Motion (P#9) Allowed (BMC 1/23/98) 11/03/1999 12 Amended complaint of Nancy Pilotte 11/03/1999 13 ANSWER: Defendants Shuh Sheen and Volney Sheen to Amended Complaint 11/03/1999 13 with CROSSCLAIM of Defendant Volney Sheen v John Silipigno 11/03/1999 14 ANSWER by John Silipigno to CROSSCLAIM of Volney Sheen 11/03/1999 16 ANSWER by Volney Sheen to CROSSCLAIM of John Silipigno 11/03/1999 15 ANSWER AND CROSSCLAIM: Defendant John Silipigno to Amended Complaint 11/03/1999 15 and CROSSCLAIM v Volney Sheen 11/03/1999 17 SERVC RETRND: Volney Sheen (Defendant) by leaving at the last and 11/03/1999 17 usual place of abode on 2/09/98 11/03/1999 18 Affidavit under GL Chap 233 Sec 79G (as amended) re: itemized medical 11/03/1999 18 bills and return receipt filed by Defendant Shuh Sheen 11/03/1999 19 Affidavit under GL Chap 233, Sec 79G (as amended) re: itemized 11/03/1999 19 medical bills and return receipt filed by Defendant Shuh Sheen 11/03/1999 20 Affidavit under GL Chap 233, Sec 79G (as amended) re: itemized 11/03/1999 20 medical bills and return receipt filed by Plaintiff 11/03/1999 21 Affidavit under GL Chap 233, Sec 79G (as amended) re: itemized 11/03/1999 21 medical bills and return receipt filed by Plaintiff 11/03/1999 22 Affidavit under GL Chap 233, Sec 79G (as amended) re: itemized 11/03/1999 22 medical bills and return receipt filed by Defendant John Silipigno 11/03/1999 23 Stipulation of dismissal that all claims and cross-claim against 11/03/1999 23 Defendant John Sikipigno ONLY are here by DISMISSED with prejudice 11/03/1999 23 and without costs 11/03/1999 24 Affidavit under GL Chap 233, Sec 79G (as amended) re: itemized 11/03/1999 24 medical bills and return receipt filed by Plaintiff 11/03/1999 25 Stipulation of dismissal as to Defendant Shuh Sheen ONLY with 11/03/1999 25 prejudice - This stipulation does not affect claims against Defendant 11/03/1999 25 Volney Sheen 11/03/1999 27 Court finds for the Plaintiff in the amount of $45,000.00 (BMC 11/03/1999 27 10/21/99) 11/03/1999 28 JUDGMENT: After finding by the Court, Judgment entered for the 11/03/1999 28 Plaintiff in the Sum of $55,260.00 (which sum includes interest from 11/03/1999 28 12/02/97, as provided by law, with costs in the sum of $184.20 = 11/03/1999 28 Total $55,444.20 (Meagher, J) 11/03/1999 26 JUDGMENT OF DISMISSAL - A stipulation of dismissal with prejudice 11/03/1999 26 having been filed by the parties on October 20, 1999 as to the 11/03/1999 26 Defendant Shuh Sheen, the Complaint of the Plaintiff is dismissed as 11/03/1999 26 to said Defendant Shuh Sheen and a Judgment of Dismissal with 11/03/1999 26 prejudice is entered on behalf of said Defendant Shuh Sheen 11/03/1999 29 Defendant Volney Sheen's request for removal to Sup Crt with demand 11/03/1999 29 for trial by jury 11/03/1999 30 Attested copy of docket entries received 11/03/1999 31 Insistence of jury claim filed by Volney Sheen 11/08/1999 Civil action cover sheet mailed re: Appeal 11/24/1999 32 Civil action cover sheet re: appeal 03/31/2000 33 Stipulation of Dismissal (filed 03/24/00) as to plff vs deft Volney 03/31/2000 33 Sheen with prejudice and without costs JUDGMENT entered on docket 03/31/2000 33 pursuant to Mass R Civ P 58(a) as amended and notice sent to parties 03/31/2000 33 pursuant to Mass R Civ P 77(d)